IthacaPizzaReview.com

Overall rating: 10 Pizzas out of 10

The Delivery: NY Pizzeria does not deliver to Ithaca.

The Pick-up: We called ahead so our order would be ready.
Order Placed: 5:02pm
Promised: 25 minutes
Pizza Ready: 5:37pm
Actual Preparation Time: 35 minutes - Being on time is not part of their bizz model - see time warning below.

The Pizza: 10 Pizzas out of 10
Pizza Style: New York style thin crust
See who can streeeechh the cheese the longest. Their cheese is great, and when it is hot out of the oven oh-so-stretchy and wonderfully gooey. They have a really interesting selection of toppings.
Not too Salty – this is one of the least salty pizza we have tasted. Too bad they are 15 minutes away.
The crust is perfectly thin, a classic NY thin crust. Makes you want to have more than one piece on your plate (if only you could fit them.)
The sauce is flavorful.

Dining Room Facts: Great Ambiance - ideal for small town voyeurism.
NY Pizzeria is in the heart of Trumansburg and it almost seems as if everyone from town will stop or walk by, so kick back, enjoy the view, and bask in the feeling of being treated like a local in a small town full of locals and not so locals (and you might even see Whoopi Goldberg while you are there).

Bonus: they have a rock 'n roll soda selection.

Time Warning: 3 of the 5 times we ordered ahead we had to wait for our pizza to be made. Sure, waiting 5 minutes to 10 minutes is acceptable but once they said it would be 20 minutes more. After walking around T-burg for 20 minutes they then said it would be 20 minutes more again. Of course I left and swore I'd never go back. But the pizza is really good so I keep going (and of course waiting.) Maybe the key is to just order slices as those take just a minute or two to heat up ...

New York Pizzeria is located at 2 W. Main Street in Trumansburg, NY